蜜桃影视

Explore

As San Diego Hounds Families for School Bus Fees, 3 Ways to Bring District Transportation Costs Under Control

Shawn Patrick Ouellette/Portland Press Herald via Getty Images

For most families, school bus service is a given: The bus shows up; the kids go to school. But in some places, rising costs are causing districts to charge parents school transportation fees 鈥 and collect on their debts.

In one year alone, San Diego Unified School District for not paying for their kids鈥 school bus rides. According to data from the 2014鈥15 school year, the district took action against 380 parents for unpaid school transportation fees, ranging from just $10 to as much as $500.

Though the district鈥檚 actions may not sit well with many, they are not without reason: In 2014鈥15, families owed the district more than $160,000 in outstanding fees, only 15 percent of which were recouped by the collection agency.

Although this case provides a uniquely unfortunate example, school transportation is a complicated issue, which we briefly explain in our new video, 鈥.鈥 When families rely on bus service, it becomes a key component of districts鈥 instructional mission 鈥 students can鈥檛 learn if they can鈥檛 get to school.

Providing bus service can be very costly for school districts. Since 1980, the average cost per student transported has , due largely to steadily declining ridership and increasingly complex education systems. In the 2012鈥13 school year alone, districts on transportation, around 4 percent of all public education expenditures. Transportation costs also tend to be volatile and unpredictable because they shift dramatically with the cost of fuel; and because state funding for transportation has been stagnant, districts have been left to handle rising costs and volatility on their own.

Although charging parents school transportation fees in response to rising costs is a relatively uncommon practice nationwide, San Diego is not alone. A dozen states , and Hawaii charges fees at the state level, though 19 other states prohibit them. Certain districts in California, Colorado, Iowa, Kansas, Massachusetts, and Texas have begun charging parents for bus service. In a , fees ranged from $180 to $575 per student per year.

While San Diego opted to charge fees, other California districts facing cost pressures, like the San Francisco and Los Angeles unified school districts, . Both districts provide transportation to only about 5 percent of their general education populations, instead relying on local public transit systems.

But states and districts have options beyond just cutting service and charging parents. As our illustrates, there are for making school transportation more effective and efficient:

  • Investing in data and technology. Districts need more information about their transportation systems in order to improve service. Therefore, states should invest in technologies that enable districts to collect, analyze, and use information that informs operations and customer service to families.
  • Providing financial incentives for efficient design and investments. Though districts face tightening transportation budgets, most actually have few incentives to make short-term investments that yield long-term efficiency gains. States should incentivize these types of investments in their funding models.
  • Thinking more broadly about how school transportation intersects with other transit systems. In many districts, particularly those located in sizable metropolitan areas, a large transportation infrastructure likely already exists. This should be tapped by districts to spur new avenues for cooperation and collaboration with local and regional transit systems.

The fact that so many districts struggle to provide adequate bus service is a clear indication that we must start thinking bigger about school transportation.

Did you use this article in your work?

We鈥檇 love to hear how 蜜桃影视鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.

Republish This Article

We want our stories to be shared as widely as possible 鈥 for free.

Please view 蜜桃影视's republishing terms.





On 蜜桃影视 Today