蜜桃影视

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 蜜桃影视 Newsletter

When the Pennsylvania Department of Education released reading scores in December, the news was grim. Not only was performance still far below pre-COVID levels, the percentage of students meeting expectations had fallen for a fourth straight year. 

For Rachael Garnick, a former first grade teacher, the results were a reminder of how tough it’s been for schools to recover from historic declines in learning since the pandemic. 

鈥淭he literacy scores are still abysmal and we should be displeased,鈥� said Garnick, who heads the Pennsylvania Literacy Coalition. Made up of over 70 organizations, the group has pushed and state officials to fund and implement reading reform.

But despite the discouraging statewide results, she also sees districts, like in northeastern Pennsylvania and the Mohawk Area district, northwest of Pittsburgh, 鈥渢rending in the right direction,鈥� and demonstrating urgency over reading scores. Their attitude, she said, was 鈥渢he opposite of 鈥業f it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.鈥� Instead, 鈥業t鈥檚 broke; we鈥檝e got to fix it.鈥� 鈥� 

on pandemic learning loss from NWEA, an assessment company, captured that combination of frustration and hope over the state of academic recovery. About a third of schools have reached pre-COVID performance levels in reading or math, and just 14% have recovered in both subjects. But even some that were hit the hardest, like high-poverty schools, have made impressive gains.

The report was just the latest collection of results pointing to a long road ahead for most schools. Last year鈥檚 National Assessment of Educational Progress scores showed students in the majority of states losing more ground, but included a few standouts with strong progress, like Louisiana in reading and Alabama in math. And state test scores tell a similar story: few have topped pre-COVID performance.

It鈥檚 not like experts didn鈥檛 predict a slow recovery. 

鈥淚f student performance improvement follows historical prepandemic trends, it could take decades for students to fully catch up,鈥� researchers with McKinsey and Company, a consulting firm, .

Even the nation鈥檚 education chief isn鈥檛 expecting good news soon. 

鈥淚 would like to say that NAEP scores, when they come out again in January 2027, are going to show marked improvement,鈥� Education Secretary Linda McMahon said in a recent K-12 Dive . 鈥淚 don鈥檛 think they are.鈥�

But Dan Goldhaber, director of the Center for Analysis of Longitudinal Data in Education Research, said it鈥檚 important to put NWEA data, and all measures of kids鈥� learning, in context.

鈥淥ne of the reasons that we’re not seeing recovery and that the results aren’t better is because of what was happening in the decade ,鈥� he said. 鈥淭here was a slow degradation of academic achievement.鈥�

Resisters and rebounders

Schools that were able to resist further declines during the pandemic are those that are more likely to be back on track, according to NWEA鈥檚 data, which represents five million students who took the MAP Growth tests through fall 2024. Such schools make up nearly three quarters of the recovered schools.

The Los Angeles-area is one example. 

Before the pandemic, the high-poverty, majority Latino district was already seeing gains on state assessments. When testing resumed in 2022, reading scores held steady. Math scores caught up the following year, and the district has continued to post gains ever since. 

Superintendent Darin Brawley highlighted a mix of academic routines, like a math problem of the day, weekly quizzes and challenging writing assignments, that the district continued despite the disruption of school closures. Teachers were encouraged to dial back their use of smart boards in the classroom and require students to keep math and language arts journals to improve retention. 

鈥淓verything was being done on the smart board and kids weren’t notating anything,鈥� Brawley said. 鈥淐ertain things have to be worked out on paper.鈥�

NWEA data also pointed to what the researchers call 鈥渞ebounder鈥� schools, those that saw significant drops in achievement but have been able to climb their way back. High-poverty schools are among those with impressive gains, but even districts seeing higher-than-ever performance still struggle to close wide achievement gaps.

鈥淲e’ve never had scores this high in English language arts or math,鈥� said Buffy Roberts, associate superintendent of the Charleston County schools in South Carolina. 鈥淚t’s been quite phenomenal.鈥�

She was talking about , which, unlike NWEA and NAEP, aren鈥檛 comparable because states don鈥檛 all measure proficiency the same. But they can still reflect post-COVID trends if states haven鈥檛 changed their tests since 2019. 

South Carolina鈥檚 math test has remained constant. Results show that statewide, scores have nearly recovered. It鈥檚 a trend that NWEA noted as well, explaining that while schools 鈥渓ost significant ground,鈥� in math, many made 鈥渟ubstantial gains afterward.鈥�

In Charleston, 54% of students in grades three through eight met or exceeded expectations in math last year, up from 48% in 2019 and about 10 percentage points higher than the state average. The district also made the Harvard Center for Education Policy Research鈥檚 fully recovered districts in the nation last year.

Roberts pointed to a swift return to in-person instruction and high-dosage tutoring as some of the factors contributing to strong growth. But she said at the outset of the pandemic, leaders 鈥渒new there were some vulnerable groups鈥� that would need 鈥渟tructures and support to mitigate some of that learning loss.鈥�

The district鈥檚 , she explained, provided extra dollars to schools with high-poverty students even when the schools didn鈥檛 qualify for federal Title I funding. The schools used the funds for extra staff to reduce class sizes, incentives to increase attendance and mental health services.

But there鈥檚 still a lot of work to do. In fourth grade math, there鈥檚 a more than 50 percentage point gap between white and Black students, and students from wealthier families outscore students in poverty by 39 percentage points. 

鈥淲e agree that progress must be faster,鈥� the district on Facebook after a conservative community group to the disparities. 

In an analysis of scores, Education Data Center researchers, led by Brown University鈥檚 Emily Oster, were hopeful about continued math recovery in 2026. Of the 32 states that have kept the same math test since before COVID, seven met or exceeded 2019 proficiency rates: Colorado, Georgia, Iowa, Mississippi, Missouri, Rhode Island and Tennessee.

But even if they didn鈥檛, they all made some gains. Despite Pennsylvania鈥檚 decline in reading, for example, its performance in math is less than a percentage point from reaching the 2019 level. 

But the results in reading were less encouraging. Six out of 28 states have met or surpassed pre-pandemic performance. But several others, like Massachusetts, Minnesota and Oregon, remain well off that mark. 

Goldhaber, with CALDER, suggested that states haven鈥檛 seen improvement on tests because parents trust those scores less than the grades kids bring home on report cards and assignments. 

A recent reiterated that point. In a survey of over 2,000 parents, nearly three quarters said they believe grades more than tests when making decisions about their children鈥檚 learning. They鈥檙e also less likely to take action, like seeking out tutoring or other help for their child, when grades are good. 

The problem is that because of grade inflation, which was on the rise even before the pandemic, grades are a less accurate measure of how students are really doing. 

The results of that survey were no surprise to Bibb Hubbard, founder and CEO of Learning Heroes, a nonprofit that focuses on helping parents understand achievement data. She said she鈥檚 been 鈥渟creaming from the rooftops for 10 years鈥� that parents are about their kids鈥� performance. 

鈥淕ood grades do not equal grade level,鈥� she said. 鈥淧arents are deeply engaged, but we can鈥檛 afford to leave them on the sidelines relying on grades alone. The stakes are too high.鈥�

Did you use this article in your work?

We鈥檇 love to hear how 蜜桃影视鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.