This Week鈥檚 ESSA News: Science Test Debate, a Career Readiness Blind Spot, and Massachusetts Has Work to Do
- Massachusetts has work to doIn another round of feedback to states, the Department of Education wants more information from Massachusetts, a state often considered to be the most ambitious in the country when it comes to education. Education Week鈥檚 Alyson Klein breaks down the feedback:
- Massachusetts wants to measure whether students are completing 鈥渃hallenging coursework鈥 using Advanced Placement exams, International Baccalaureate tests, and honors classes. But the department pushed back, saying that not all kids have access to those courses and tests.
- The department wants Massachusetts to remove science as an indicator of academic achievement (more on this below).
- And it wants more information on how the state will decide about school improvement 鈥 both in identifying which schools need extra support based on subgroup performance and how it will decide when a low-performing school can exit that status.

Trump Ed. Dept.: High-Achieving Massachusetts Has Some ESSA Work to Do
鈥 Politics K-12 (@PoliticsK12)
-
What if states want to use science assessments?
Much of the debate over this stemmed from criticism over the way states want to integrate science tests into their accountability systems, so Education Week how states can use these other assessments under ESSA. Alyson Klein clarifies that 鈥渟tates can use science test scores to judge both kinds of schools,鈥 meaning elementary/middle schools and high schools, but 鈥渢hey need to meet certain requirements.鈥 So far, Connecticut, Delaware, Louisiana, Tennessee, and other states can do it, but they must be used as an聽鈥渋ndicator of school quality and student success, or as the second academic indicator for elementary and middle schools.鈥
. examined how states can use science, social studies, & the arts as accountability measures:
鈥 ESSA Updates (@ESSA_Update)
-
States are missing an opportunity to address career readiness
Advance CTE and the Education Strategy Group state ESSA plans for mentions of career readiness. And what they found was disappointing. While more than half plan to adopt measures of career readiness in their accountability systems, several states 鈥渕issed an opportunity to fully leverage ESSA to advance a statewide vision of career readiness.鈥
New study looks at what states are doing to build readiness into their plans:
鈥 Achieve (@AchieveInc)
-
How do long-term research-practice partnerships fit into ESSA?
ESSA asks schools, districts, and states to select 鈥渆vidence-based programs鈥 for its plans. So, the University of Colorado鈥檚 Bill Penuel and Caitlin C. Farrell 鈥渁 number of scenarios where long-term research-practice partnerships (RPPs) have helped districts select, adapt, and design evidence-based programs.鈥
They note that these partnerships are 鈥渓ong-term, mutually beneficial relationships between practitioners and researchers around problems of practice.鈥 Two strong examples they cite are the University of Chicago Consortium on School Research鈥檚 work with Illinois to support the implementation of a 鈥渇ifth indicator鈥 for school accountability, describing it as being 鈥渋n many ways ahead of other states,鈥 and the contribution the Tennessee Education Research Alliance has made to that state鈥檚 ESSA plan.
An opportunity for research-practice partnerships to support districts and states
鈥 NEPC (@NEPCtweet)
Did you use this article in your work?
We鈥檇 love to hear how 蜜桃影视鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.