Union Report: Mysterious Turnovers of Top Staff May Come as a Surprise, but They Are the Norm for the NEA and Its Affiliates
Mike Antonucci鈥檚 Union Report appears most Wednesdays; see the full archive.
In the National Education Association governance system, the executive director is the most senior, highest-paid employee. He or she acts as chief of staff, overseeing all aspects of the union鈥檚 operations and deployment of personnel on the orders of the elected officers. But the executive director is often a player in union 鈥 and government 鈥 politics in his or her own right.
Executive directors tend to last a long time, which is an internal advantage since most elected officers are term-limited. So when one of them resigns, is dismissed or non-renewed, or experiences some other type of job separation that is not easily explained, it generates a lot of speculation.
In a matter of months, both NEA national and its largest state affiliate, the California Teachers Association, saw executive director turnover.
At the national union, John Stocks stepped down last month from the position he had held since 2011. He concurrently serves as chairman of the board of the , a network of wealthy progressive political donors. He will continue in that role while acting as a senior adviser at NEA until after the 2020 elections.
His successor as NEA executive director is , a longtime senior staffer at the union who for the past three years has been executive vice president of the Democracy Alliance.
The arrangement allows Stocks to direct the campaign strategies of both NEA and the Democracy Alliance while leaving all other duties in Anderson鈥檚 hands.
鈥淚 had become deeply disturbed by the course of our country and was being called to devote all of my time, my talents and my energy to the cause of saving our democracy,鈥 Stocks told the NEA board of directors in February.
While Stocks will be saving our democracy, it isn鈥檛 yet clear what former California Teachers Association executive director Joe Nu帽ez will be up to.
Nu帽ez had served in that post for six years, after a long career in the union鈥檚 management. The board abruptly with Nu帽ez last week.
I admit I was taken by surprise, as were other observers and union insiders. cited 鈥渁 source who is familiar with the CTA鈥檚 internal power dynamics鈥 who suggested that 鈥渢he move reflected lingering anger over to become CTA president 鈥 an outcome widely seen as an upset given Monta帽o鈥檚 position in the CTA hierarchy.鈥
That may be the case, or it may be something entirely hidden from view. Changes at the top of NEA state affiliates are often shrouded in mystery, as any internal turmoil tends to ruin the public image the unions prefer to portray.
A quick spin through my archives reveals just how prevalent this secrecy is.
The Idaho Education Association split with Executive Director Sue Wigdorski in October. 鈥淲hile Wigdorski鈥檚 departure is unexplained, the timing appears abrupt,鈥 read .
Richard Sanders, the executive director of the Oregon Education Association, resigned without warning in 2016. No explanation was given, though he was unpopular with the staff.
The Florida Education Association removed chiefs of staff without explanation in both 2008 and 2011. The South Carolina Education Association split with executive directors unexpectedly in both 2006 and 2007. Education Minnesota lost several senior staffers, including its executive director, in 2007.
Three other state affiliate executive directors separated after allegations of wrongdoing. NEA Alaska鈥檚 Tom Harvey resigned in 2006 after a against him. The Alabama Education Association , for failure to 鈥渕eet his obligations toward the sound financial operation of AEA.鈥 The Indiana State Teachers Association dismissed Executive Director Warren Williams in 2009 for . The union sued Williams .
Teachers unions are private enterprises, so if they want to be secretive about churn at top management levels, it is their right. But their relations with their own supervisors and staff suggest that they are far from model employers.
Did you use this article in your work?
We鈥檇 love to hear how 蜜桃影视鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.