What鈥檚 an Emotion Scientist? Inside the New Concept Shaping Social-Emotional Learning
When Nilda Irizarry was a sophomore in her Springfield, Massachusetts, high school, she didn鈥檛 raise her hand and she didn鈥檛 participate in class discussions. Although she loved learning, she was certain she didn鈥檛 fit in.
But her teacher Patricia Gardner saw something very different. One day, she pulled Irizarry aside and asked why she didn鈥檛 speak up more, because she was such a good writer. Irizarry said that she didn鈥檛 feel smart and didn鈥檛 want to be embarrassed.
鈥溾楴o, your ideas are worthy,鈥欌 Irizarry recalled Gardner saying. 鈥溾榊ou need to know you can do this.鈥欌
Irizarry 鈥 now a middle school principal in Farmington, Connecticut 鈥 didn鈥檛 have a term for it then, but her teacher was acting as an 鈥渆motion scientist,鈥 a new phrase that describes what some educators have been doing for a long time: investigating what lies behind student behavior. If you haven鈥檛 heard the phrase, you probably will soon. The concept 鈥 coined by Marc Brackett, director of the 鈥 is becoming increasingly popular through its use in the Center鈥檚 social-emotional learning program, . Helping students and teachers investigate their emotions can lead to healthier humans and better learners, Brackett said.
Brackett has used the phrase for several years, but he really only started to explicitly define it as he was writing his book, , to be released in September. When Brackett talks about 鈥渆motion scientists,鈥 he often contrasts the phrase with 鈥渆motion judges鈥 鈥 people who are quick to label someone else鈥檚 emotions or dismiss them without figuring out what鈥檚 behind their reactions.
He estimates that the world is likely filled with far more emotion judges than scientists because it鈥檚 much easier to quickly make assumptions about someone else鈥檚 feelings. But this can create problems in schools if educators and students incorrectly make assumptions about each other鈥檚 feelings and experiences 鈥 and subsequently make decisions based on those false inferences.
A teacher, for example, might think a student with his head on his desk is bored and being disrespectful. In reality, that student might be depressed or tired. If the teacher doesn鈥檛 first investigate what the issue is, there鈥檚 a risk that the underlying problem will go unresolved, Brackett said.
鈥淗ow many times have any of us been misread?鈥 Brackett said.鈥淚t鈥檚 a big 鈥榓ha!鈥 for teachers because they realize how frequently they probably are misreading students.鈥
Irizarry, who now works at Irving A. Robbins Middle School and attended the RULER training with Brackett this summer, discovered that she was finally able to put a label on how her teacher had helped her years ago.
鈥淪he acted as an emotion scientist,鈥 Irizarry said. 鈥淚 didn鈥檛 realize that until the training. She sought to know me as a person and a learner.鈥
The work requires teaching both educators and students to ask themselves questions about how they鈥檙e feeling, why they might be feeling this way, and how they can regulate their feelings so that they can continue teaching and learning. For teachers to be able to set aside their own feelings to address uncomfortable student behavior, they also have to be trained on how to understand and regulate their own emotions, Brackett said.
Adrienne Wheeler, assistant principal of Justus C. Richardson Middle School in Massachusetts, who also attended the RULER training at Yale, sees this work as important for not only her teaching staff but also the students who are sent to her office for discipline. Before staff meetings, for example, Wheeler plans to use the 鈥淢ood Meter,鈥 a RULER tool that allows staff to privately share their energy levels and emotions. This then helps Wheeler understand what her team members need before she puts them to work.
It鈥檚 important to build a relationship with students, Wheeler said, so she can figure out the root cause of misbehavior. Often after summer vacations or long breaks, students might act up more frequently because something may have changed in their family life while away from school. Asking questions to understand this greater context is important to addressing the real problem, she said.
鈥淓motion scientist鈥 might sound like an oxymoron 鈥斅燼fter all, can something as intangible as a feeling be understood? Some of the educators Brackett has worked with have also been skeptical, questioning whether it is really necessary to invest time toward dissecting emotions during a school day packed with academics. And Brackett admits this work does take time.
But educators like Wheeler who have seen how emotions affect academics aren鈥檛 surprised by the phrase.
鈥淲hen I think of science, I think of an action and a reaction, and for every cause there鈥檚 an effect, and I see a correlation there with emotions,鈥 Wheeler said.
Both Wheeler鈥檚 district in Massachusetts and Irizarry鈥檚 district in Connecticut are adopting the RULER approach to social-emotional learning this year, but both said they鈥檝e been practicing this kind of work in their schools already. Research shows that having support for social-emotional learning in school can boost academics, increase graduation rates and improve student well-being.
鈥淗elping students collaborate, be autonomous in the classroom 鈥 all of those things are emotionally based,鈥 Irizarry said. 鈥淓motional intelligence is as important as academic intelligence.鈥
Disclosure: The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative provides financial support to 补苍诲听蜜桃影视.
Did you use this article in your work?
We鈥檇 love to hear how 蜜桃影视鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.